[SUGGESTION]For Improvement :D

[Vote4DJz]

1.In the game,make an option for BPMs.

2.In profile make a profile editor.

3.In the game, make a background theme that can change in colors or designs.

4.In chat, make the scroll not just like that,make it like the scroll in the music library .

5.Before loading Music Library why not Loading only why Preloading.

6.Full AAAs, when you AAA Easy,Medium,Hard call it Full AAA.

7.In level stats, why Play Donut Genocide on Thirdstyle my suggestion should be Donut Genocide on Thirdstyle then by: Oscillator Z and in the players list why not make it exact for example 99.87, 96.87.

8.Fix the missing levels like this: http://thirdstyle.com/stats/level_scores/50


MY SUGGESTION :D

[xMUSICxMASTERx]

#1 if you mean a search option, kind of pointless

#2 There is a profile editor, it just doesn't have that many features yet

#3 This could be nice, sort of like the idea to change the TS theme overall but many people disagreed with it.

#4 It probably wouldn't look that good

#5 Because the game is preloading, it's only preparing songs to be loaded. Sort of hard to explain

#6 This could be interesting, although, if you can AAA something on hard then you can probably AAA the other difficulties so it's sort of useless to show off a "full AAA" when you can just show off the hard AAA.

#7 I suppose "Play Donut Genocide on Thirdstyle" makes it clear that you can press the Donut Genocide link to play the song directly. And the percenteges are rounded probably so it doesn't look so messy and because no one would care what the exact percentage is when you can just look at the score right beside it.

#8 lol yes.

[Spiller]

And the percenteges are rounded probably so it doesn't look so messy and because no one would care what the exact percentage is when you can just look at the score right beside it.

I care a lot. Score and percentage are two different ratings and honestly I prefer the percentage. Your score is also based on your combos, so getting FC can really improve your score. It isn't that obvious exactly because it is rounded in those lists, but even then it is not hard to find someone with 97% scoring higher than one with 99%.

#8, looks like the level is deleted and I couldn't find it in the level list. Does this link appear anywhere?

[Housekeeper]

http://thirdstyle.com/forum/showthre...ons-Thread-(-)

[DrugstoreCowboy]

#8. Im pretty sure that happens because of the way an admin (not sure who. probably tass.) deleted a file/song when uploading. Its just the way it is. ^_^

[Nocturne]

I care a lot. Score and percentage are two different ratings and honestly I prefer the percentage. Your score is also based on your combos, so getting FC can really improve your score.

You kind of contradicted your own point there lol, you may care about percentage more, but ultimately, leaderboards are ranked on score, no? Which you just pointed out are not percentage based. lolol

Also percentage is cool and all, but exact percentage I personally don't care about, since obviously I'm only looking to raise my high score, not concerned specifically with percentage. And it's not like I'm gonna consistently check my percentage mid-play, cuz that'll ruin my focus, ergo I'll be playing the whole song altogether, so it's really no a big deal if I'm playing through to improve score.

6.Full AAAs, when you AAA Easy,Medium,Hard call it Full AAA.

Naw full AAA sounds too awkward, don't give it a name, but make it reward something in return, possibly the obtainment of a "challenge" file? Or even just FC'ing all Difficulties should open Challenge File.

[kisler]

1. Sorting? Nah.
2. Exists already.
3. Ew no.
4.

Ew no.

5. The game is preloading the library and stage. When you go to play a song, it's loading the files for that song.
6.

Ew no.

7. This is actually a somewhat good idea...maybe have a rank by % option? Rank by score is still superior though.
8. They don't exist, so leave 'em alone :D :D :D

[cheezpuffs]

I like the idea of no.6, if the song itself turns gold afterwards, that'd be better too!

[Spiller]

You kind of contradicted your own point there lol, you may care about percentage more, but ultimately, leaderboards are ranked on score, no? Which you just pointed out are not percentage based. lolol

Yeah, leaderboards are based on score, which is a flaw in my opinion since the score system is biased. If you get a BF, it doesn't matter where that one great happened. However if that one great was a boo or miss, it suddenly matters a lot where that boo/miss was. And that is ridiculous to me.
So while I want to compare myself with others, I don't want to compare based on a rating I don't believe in. While percentage isn't perfect (as you can't tell if it is that persons highest percentage) I still find it more informative than score.

To be fair I don't think the scoring system is that bad, it works okay for me as long as the scores aren't in the 98-99% range. (On the other hand, it is difficult to judge the performance of others based on only score.) It is much better than other attempts on scoring systems like Osu! with quadratic growth based on combo and Stepmania 4 (and maybe 5 too) which is exponential based on the current time. (I don't remember the equation exactly, but it was something like that. (I'm very curios to how exactly it is implemented in TS though, if anyone knows I would love to hear it.)

TL;DR
Basically it boils down to that I think of combo, FC and AAA as achievements and that achievements shouldn't affect your score, so I want that percentage is accurate enough so I can use that for my own judging.


#6, I agree with xMUSICxMASTERx, once you get the hard AAA it is easy to get the two others. As a stat it wouldn't be that informative, so unless it unlocks something like Nocturne suggested I don't see the point. What cheezpuffs suggested would be cool too.